Skip to main content
800-457-4406

My Order

Cart is Empty

Product Guide

Waterproof vs Water-Resistant Tarps: Understanding the Difference

By John Flemming May 12, 2025 Product Guide

heavy duty waterproof tarp treated with canvak

Tarps (short for tarpaulins) are essential for protecting equipment, materials, and outdoor spaces. However, not all tarps are created equal; some are fully waterproof, while others are water-resistant and allow for light airflow.

Understanding this difference helps homeowners, contractors, farmers, and truckers select the best heavy duty tarp for the job.

Waterproof Tarps

A waterproof tarp is completely impervious to water. Its sealed surface prevents moisture from passing through, even during heavy rain or submersion.

These heavy-duty tarps are often made from vinyl or polyethylene coatings that create a durable, watertight barrier. However, because they also block air circulation, they can trap condensation if moisture is sealed underneath.

Ideal uses:

  • Protecting valuable machinery or freight during transport
  • Creating leak diverter tarps for industrial use
  • Covering construction materials or vehicles

Water-Resistant Tarps

Water-resistant tarps repel water to a degree but are not entirely waterproof. These tarps usually have a specialized coating (typically a wax, oil, or silicone fabric treatment) to cause water to bead and roll off.

While effective for light to moderate rain, prolonged exposure will allow moisture through. The advantage? They are much more breathable, helping prevent mold and condensation.

Best for:

  • Temporary outdoor protection
  • Farm equipment or hay covers
  • Applications where airflow and breathability matter

Materials Matter: Poly, Vinyl, Canvas, and Mesh Tarps

The material defines whether a tarp is waterproof or water-resistant, along with its breathability and durability. Below are four main tarp materials:

Tarp TypeWater RepellencyBreathabilityBest Uses
Polyethylene TarpWaterproofNoneConstruction site covers, roof patches
Vinyl TarpWaterproofNoneEquipment covers, building enclosures
Canvas TarpWater-ResistantModerateLumber or hay covers
Mesh TarpNoneHighShade covers, truck bed nets

Polyethylene Tarps (Poly Tarps)

Poly tarps are woven from plastic (often laminated) and are inherently 100% waterproof. They’re lightweight yet durable, offering an excellent strength-to-weight ratio.

They resist stretching and tearing but can become brittle with prolonged UV exposure. Though not as long-lasting as vinyl, they are an affordable, waterproof tarp option for quick coverage.

Common uses:

  • Covering construction materials or wood piles
  • Temporary roof or leak protection
  • Camping ground cloths

 

Woven Poly Ad from the 70s
Humphrys Ad for Poly tarps from the early 1970s.

Vinyl Tarps (PVC Tarps)

Vinyl tarps are the most durable heavy duty tarps available, fully waterproof and resistant to UV rays, abrasions, tearing, and chemicals. Made from PVC-coated polyester, these vinyl tarps excel in harsh industrial conditions and are ideal for long-term, all-weather coverage.

Best applications:

  • Industrial machinery protection
  • Trucking and freight (e.g., vinyl lumber tarps)
  • Construction enclosures and flatbed covers

Canvas Tarps

Canvas tarps are crafted from cotton fabric treated with waterproofing agents. While not fully waterproof, they are highly water-resistant and allow airflow, reducing condensation and mildew buildup.

Their breathability makes them ideal for protecting items sensitive to moisture, like wood, hay, or equipment.

Top uses:

  • Covering farm supplies or tools
  • Storage protection for lumber or furniture
  • Camping and outdoor shelters
Canvas Tarp Ad from the early 1900s
Before poly and vinyl tarps, canvas was used for everything.

Mesh Tarps

Mesh tarps are not waterproof; they allow full airflow and moisture passage. They are uniquely designed for ventilation, shade, and wind reduction rather than water protection.

Perfect for:

  • Shading patios or greenhouses
  • Truck beds or debris containment
  • Agricultural ventilation covers

Choosing the Right Tarp

The right choice comes down to your environment and how long the tarp needs to perform.

For jobs that demand complete water protection — construction sites, freight transport, industrial equipment covers — choose a vinyl tarp or poly tarp. Both are fully waterproof and block 100% of moisture.

For applications where breathability matters — lumber storage, hay covers, farm equipment, or anything prone to condensation and mildew — a canvas tarp provides water resistance while allowing airflow. Re-treat with Canvak Canvas Protectant to maintain the water-repellent finish over time.

For targeted leak management inside warehouses, factories, or commercial buildings, Leak Diverter Tarps channel water away from equipment and inventory without disrupting operations.

Shop Durable, Waterproof, and Heavy Duty Tarps from Humphrys Textiles

Since 1874, Humphrys Textile Products has manufactured heavy duty tarps at our facilities in Philadelphia, PA and Gosport, IN. With over 150 years of American manufacturing expertise, we know the strengths and trade-offs of every tarp material firsthand.

Whether you need a fully waterproof vinyl tarp for industrial applications, a breathable canvas tarp for farm and equipment covers, or a heavy duty poly tarp for construction site protection, our team is ready to help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are tarps waterproof?

Some tarps are fully waterproof (like vinyl and poly tarps), while others, such as canvas tarps, are only water-resistant. Always check the tarp material and coating before purchase.

What is the best tarp for heavy rain?

For sustained rainfall or pooling water, vinyl tarps are the best choice. They’re completely waterproof, durable, and resistant to UV and tearing.

Can you make a canvas tarp more waterproof?

Yes! Apply a Canvak Waterproofing Treatment or similar sealant regularly to improve water repellency and extend the tarp’s lifespan.

What’s the difference between waterproof and water-resistant tarps?

Waterproof tarps block all water penetration, while water-resistant tarps repel moisture but can eventually soak through during prolonged exposure.

Are tarpaulins waterproof?

It depends on the material. "Tarpaulin" is simply the full word for "tarp" — vinyl and polyethylene tarpaulins are fully waterproof, while canvas tarpaulins are water-resistant. The material and any applied coatings determine the level of water protection.

Are poly tarps waterproof?

Yes. Polyethylene (poly) tarps are inherently waterproof. The laminated plastic material creates a complete moisture barrier. Humphrys' Heavy Duty Poly Tarps are a full 20 mil thick, providing maximum durability and waterproof protection for construction sites, equipment storage, and emergency roof coverage.

What is the most breathable waterproof tarp?

No tarp is both fully waterproof and fully breathable — these properties work against each other. However, treated canvas tarps offer the best balance of water resistance and breathability, making them ideal for covering lumber, hay, and equipment where airflow prevents condensation and mildew. To maintain the water-repellent treatment on a canvas tarp, apply Canvak Canvas Protectant as needed.

What is the strongest waterproof tarp material?

Vinyl (PVC-coated polyester) is the strongest waterproof tarp material available. Heavy duty vinyl tarps resist UV rays, tearing, abrasion, and chemicals while maintaining complete waterproof protection. At 18 oz per square yard, Humphrys' vinyl tarps are built for the toughest industrial and commercial applications.

Get a Free Quote

Ready to order or looking for more info? We’re here to help!

Questions?

Call Us Today!

800-457-4406

Visit Us

Pennsylvania:
5000 Paschall Ave
Philadelphia, PA 19134

Indiana:
11 Lousisa St.
Gosport, IN 47433

Get in touch today! We’ve got you covered.